Director: Ridley Scott
Rating: 2 Stars
Ah, disappointment burns brightly for me on this one. I had reasonably high expectations going in... I wasn't sure the movie would be all that popular, but I thought I would like it. Ridley Scott and I go back a ways, as it happens. His film, Gladiator, is one of my very favorite movies. The director's cut (please! stay away from the theatrical release) of Kingdom of Heaven
And that's what torpedoes this movie for me... Ridley Scott gave in (or was forced to) ridiculously sappy egregious romanticism. For the first four fifths of this movie I was genuinely enjoying myself. It paid plenty of attention to historical details of the period (in this case just after of the Third Crusade) and was engaged in the telling of a generally interesting take on the Robin Hood tale. In this version, Robin is a common longbowman who'd accompanied Richard the Lionhearted's army to the Holy Land. For those of you who are interested in that kind of thing, I did some checking and a lot of what you see in the movie are historical episodes (though none that ever confirmed the existence of Robin Hood).
Anyway, Robin eventually finds himself in a major squabble between the crown and many lords (spurred on by overly evil French agents) on the question of divine right of kings versus free will and god-given rights of the individual. It seemed a little far-fetched while I was watching, but as I said, the history isn't exactly bad as far as all this was concerned. The plot was fine, and the characters were reasonably engaging, and the acting was all quite good... But, it all came apart during the final battle for me. It felt very unrealistic and full of Hollywood cliche. Exactly what I did not expect from Mr. Scott. My wife and I both laughed out loud at least once during the final battle scene, and it all ended up essentially ruining the movie for me.
C'est la vie, I guess. I feel almost as betrayed by this one as I felt by the theatrical release of Kingdom of Heaven. Here's to hoping the studio interfered with Ridley again and we'll all be treated to a future director's cut release of Robin Hood with a completely different battle scene... Or something.
(2 stars)